“Heart Matters” - book review by Guest Blogger Ooi Boon-Teck
Inspired by my father’s guest blogging stint, his younger brother (Uncle No. 2) has offered a book review of the memoir by Canadian Governor General Adrienne Clarkson about her “fusion life”. Uncle Boon-Teck is a Canadian citizen and I am pleased to learn something about Canadian current affairs from this book review. Also, this seems particularly apt given my post on Monday about Canadians…
He writes:
Nowadays, not only cabinet ministers, freshly out of office, feel impelled to write memoirs to defend their record but heads-of-state too. In the latter part of her Governor-Generalship of Canada (1999-2005), Adrienne Clarkson was criticized for extravagance in her state visits. As the Liberal party in power was herself embroiled in a corruption scandal, the Prime Minister was in no position to take a stand on her behalf.
I am happy that Adrienne Clarkson wrote HEART MATTERS because a memoir cannot just be a justification of public decisions but there must be an accounting of a life leading to them. I find her biographical part interesting—the story of a girl born Adrienne Poy, escaping from Japanese capture of Hong Kong in 1942, becoming a TV hostess of the Canadian Broadcasting Company, having her own show “Adrienne Clarkson Presents” and finally becoming the Governor-General.
Before her Governor-Generalship, Canadian-Chinese had as much disowned her as being “not enough Chinese”. This “ostracism”, not that she would care, was totally unjustified because her father was an Australian born Chinese and her mother’s family was from Dutch Guyana (now Surinam ). Of course, after reaching the vice-regal status, we did not claim her as our own fast enough.
Whereas most immigrant stories have been about the first generation adapting to a new culture, Adrienne Clarkson’s story is a rarity because her family has already been accustomed to English culture. The documentation of her experiences is valuable because they correspond to those of the second and third generation English-educated Malaysians and Singaporeans.
The colourful person in her memoir and a key person in her life was her father, William Poy. He was a survivor who took risky gambles. As a boy he rode horses bareback in Australia . In Hong Kong , he owned horses, rode them in flat and steeple races and became a member of the social set of the Jockey Club. He had lady-killer good looks. One family photo shows him in jodhpur with a hat tilted rakishly. Another was by Yousof Karsh, famous for his portraits of Winston Churchill and Albert Einstein. I did not know that Yousof Karsh did portraits of nonentities.
Somehow in 1942, he managed to have his family listed with the Canadians to be shipped out of Hong Kong by the Japanese to be exchanged in Mozambique for a ship load Japanese nationals captured by the Allies.
The memoirs let slip the sense of values held by the Poy family. From Mozambique , their ship crossed the south Atlantic to Rio de Janeiro before working its way to Canada . At Rio , the Red Cross gave them ten dollars each. They went on a shopping spree–alligator shoes, alligator handbags, a silk frock for Adrienne and a silk shirt for her brother. Whereas another family would have squirreled away the money, this family preferred “elegance”.
Settling in Ottawa , William Poy was a doting father who read to the growing Adrienne a bed time story every night. He made believe with her that when she grew up they would go to the opera together. He imagined for her the balconies and the curtains of the opera hall, the beautiful gowns and jewelry worn by the audience.
All these fineries, which he dreamed for her, came true.
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Written by Guest Blogger: Prof. Ooi Boon-Teck
~~~~~~~~~~~~
You can buy a copy of “Heart Matters” from the Amazon.ca (the Canadian Amazon site).
Update: Micheal Beck’s blog, The Sovereign Journey, offers some further thoughts on the Chinese in Canada with a discussion about dual citizenship issues.
Photo: thanks to dfait-maeci.gc.ca
Posted by Yang-May Ooi on Thursday, November 30th, 2006 at 7:00am








Working on the Malaysian English of 

I also came across Vicky Lee Wei Kay’s Irish-born Chinese blog at










